I Tested 7 Supposedly ‘Best’ Keloid Treatments—Only 1 Helped (and One Made It Worse)



 Let me guess: you Googled “how to get rid of a keloid,” and suddenly you’re knee-deep in a vortex of expensive creams, Reddit rabbit holes, and dermatologist jargon. That was me—desperate, frustrated, and tired of throwing money at what felt like hope in a jar.

This is not a sponsored post. I’m not a doctor. I’m just someone who had a persistent, angry keloid on my shoulder that made me weirdly self-conscious—and I tried everything to get rid of it.

Here’s what worked. And what really didn’t.


First: The Keloid Struggle Is Very Real

If you’ve never had a keloid, it’s easy to think it’s “just a scar.”
But if you have one (or more), you already know: they itch, they throb, they grow past the original wound, and they absolutely mess with your confidence. The worst part? Even when you treat them, they come back like a villain in a sequel no one asked for.

That’s why this article exists—because trial-and-error treatments are exhausting, and I wish I had this list when I started.


The 7 Treatments I Tried (and the Raw Truth About Each One)

1. Silicone Sheets (ScarAway, etc.)

Verdict: Mildly Effective if You’re Relentlessly Consistent
I wore these religiously for 3 months, even sleeping with them on. The keloid softened a bit, but never shrank. The upside? It stopped itching. The downside? You’ll go broke restocking them if your scar is big.

Wish I knew: They’re better for fresh scars, not old battle wounds.

 Start Your Free 30-Day Amazon Prime Trial


2. Corticosteroid Injections

Verdict: Most Effective—But Painful and Temporary
This was the only thing that visibly shrank my keloid. After 3 sessions spaced a few weeks apart, it reduced by about 50%. But here’s the catch: after 6 months, it started creeping back.

Wish I knew: Maintenance injections may be needed. Also, the needle? Not fun.


3. Apple Cider Vinegar (ACV) Compresses

Verdict: Did Literally Nothing
It stung. It smelled. And after 4 weeks of religious application? No change—unless you count the rash it gave me.

Wish I knew: Pinterest is not a dermatologist.


4. Onion Extract Gels (Mederma)

Verdict: Overrated and Overhyped
Everyone swears by Mederma. My wallet disagrees. Used twice a day for 10 weeks, and I saw… maybe a 5% difference?

Wish I knew: Marketing > Results in this case.


5. Laser Therapy

Verdict: Promising but Pricey and Not for Everyone
My dermatologist warned me that lasers can sometimes worsen pigmentation in darker skin tones. We tried one session cautiously. The redness faded a bit, but no size reduction.

Wish I knew: It’s not a one-size-fits-all fix. Always ask about risks, especially for melanated skin.


6. Cryotherapy (Freezing the Keloid)

Verdict: Made It Worse—And I Regret It Deeply
This is the one that backfired. It scabbed. Peeled. Then regrew bigger. I was devastated.

Wish I knew: Cryo has a high recurrence rate, especially on keloids that already had injections. Don't stack aggressive treatments too fast.


7. Pressure Earrings / Dressings (for Earlobe Keloids)

Verdict: Surprisingly Effective for Newer Scars
If your keloid is from a piercing, these clip-on pressure earrings (after steroid injections) do help flatten them. Mine wasn’t on my ear, but a friend had great results.

Wish I knew: The location of the scar changes everything.


So… What Actually Helped?

Steroid injections + patience were the only combo that worked visibly. Everything else either helped slightly, not at all, or made it worse.

And here’s the biggest truth: you need to treat keloids like a chronic skin condition, not a one-time fix. They are stubborn, and recurrence is common.


The Emotional Side No One Talks About

I hated wearing sleeveless tops. I hated people asking, “What happened there?” I spent too long being embarrassed about something I didn’t cause.

Keloids mess with more than just your skin—they mess with how you feel in it.

So if you’re dealing with this right now: you’re not alone. And you're not vain or weird for wanting it gone.


Final Advice (From Someone Who’s Been There)

  • Start early if you can. Fresh keloids are easier to treat.

  • Less is more—don’t attack your skin with 5 treatments at once.

  • See a dermatologist before spending hundreds on products.

  • Manage expectations. The goal might be reduction, not total disappearance.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Dry, Tight Skin That Never Feels Moisturized? These Natural Face Moisturizers Actually Fix It

  If you have dry skin, you already know the routine. You apply moisturizer. Your skin feels better… for about 20 minutes . Then the tigh...